Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PALLADIUM - NEW YORK MERCANTILE EXCHANGE   (CONTRACTS OF 100 TROY OUNCES)                                      :
CFTC Code #075651                                                    Open Interest is    23,657                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:    2,430    10,316     3,898     1,939       949    10,704     4,754       171     2,806     3,407       573 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:      246      -368     1,400      -652       184      -534     1,841        56      -105       166       -28 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     10.3      43.6      16.5       8.2       4.0      45.2      20.1       0.7      11.9      14.4       2.4 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:   157                     :
:       13        18        14        10         9        33        22         6        26        23         7 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PLATINUM - NEW YORK MERCANTILE EXCHANGE   (CONTRACTS OF 50 TROY OUNCES)                                        :
CFTC Code #076651                                                    Open Interest is    73,441                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:    5,126    26,688     3,949    10,101     2,256    30,422    22,684     2,369    20,395     5,245       637 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:     -416       399    -1,150     1,666       378     2,882      -523       157    -1,062    -1,018        63 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:      7.0      36.3       5.4      13.8       3.1      41.4      30.9       3.2      27.8       7.1       0.9 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:   240                     :
:       16        18        10        13         7        54        31        23        85        15         9 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SILVER - COMMODITY EXCHANGE INC.   (CONTRACTS OF 5,000 TROY OUNCES)                                            :
CFTC Code #084691                                                    Open Interest is   220,888                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   15,618    65,644    25,623    56,164    23,397    67,625    18,565    16,510    23,411     7,023    18,242 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:     -824     1,368      -906       450     3,355     1,019    -7,362    -1,605    -2,620       185      -853 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:      7.1      29.7      11.6      25.4      10.6      30.6       8.4       7.5      10.6       3.2       8.3 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:   230                     :
:       16        23        14        13        18        61        20        30        61        23        48 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
GOLD - COMMODITY EXCHANGE INC.   (CONTRACTS OF 100 TROY OUNCES)                                                :
CFTC Code #088691                                                    Open Interest is   739,201                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   48,219   174,322    33,939   157,232   116,194   208,471    35,939    73,494    87,594    35,219   114,636 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:   -1,623    13,238     2,115     2,054      -509     7,903   -12,823    -3,266      -403     7,829    -3,211 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:      6.5      23.6       4.6      21.3      15.7      28.2       4.9       9.9      11.8       4.8      15.5 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:   413                     :
:       30        35        14        19        23       105        34        56       120        70        94 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
COPPER-GRADE #1 - COMMODITY EXCHANGE INC.   (CONTRACTS OF 25,000 POUNDS)                                       :
CFTC Code #085692                                                    Open Interest is   204,508                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   26,447    72,388    45,915     6,496     1,331    67,806    44,466     9,726    20,814    32,866    16,379 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:   -6,346    12,909        40       208       347    11,516   -28,518    -2,589   -13,649     1,164       838 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     12.9      35.4      22.5       3.2       0.7      33.2      21.7       4.8      10.2      16.1       8.0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:   307                     :
:       31        49        18         5         6        58        51        35        47        65        39 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ALUMINUM MW US TR PLATTS SWAP - COMMODITY EXCHANGE INC.   (25 METRIC TONS)                                     :
CFTC Code #191693                                                    Open Interest is    30,013                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:    7,513    28,500     6,678       534        59     2,310         0         0    13,029       252        24 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:      246       340       -55         0         0        90         0         0       -40         0         0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     25.0      95.0      22.3       1.8       0.2       7.7       0.0       0.0      43.4       0.8       0.1 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    27                     :
:        7        17         .         .         .         .         0         0         .         .         . :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
HOT ROLLED COIL STEEL - NEW YORK MERCANTILE EXCHANGE   (CONTRACTS OF 20 SHORT TONS)                            :
CFTC Code #192651                                                    Open Interest is    16,864                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:    2,347       475     6,545         0         0       964     2,526       130     6,267    13,085       578 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:     -327      -217    -1,130         0         0        -8       -75         8      -892    -2,057      -188 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     13.9       2.8      38.8       0.0       0.0       5.7      15.0       0.8      37.2      77.6       3.4 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    23                     :
:        7         .         .         0         0         .         .         .         7         .         . :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IRON ORE 62% FE, CFR CHINA TSI - NEW YORK MERCANTILE EXCHANGE   (CONTRACTS OF 500 DRY METRIC TONS)             :
CFTC Code #195651                                                    Open Interest is    20,308                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:    5,422     4,845         0         0         0     1,339     5,201       916     7,300     3,739     3,724 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:     -428      -269         0         0         0       -30       117       -60       227        44       -52 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     26.7      23.9       0.0       0.0       0.0       6.6      25.6       4.5      35.9      18.4      18.3 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    58                     :
:       14        14         0         0         0         6         4         .        20        12        19 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RANDOM LENGTH LUMBER - CHICAGO MERCANTILE EXCHANGE   (CONTRACTS OF 110,000 BOARD FEET)                         :
CFTC Code #058643                                                    Open Interest is     4,191                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:      971     1,660        92         0         0       555       800        11       926       476       234 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:      441      -273         8         0         0      -274       297        11      -227        -8       -77 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     23.2      39.6       2.2       0.0       0.0      13.2      19.1       0.3      22.1      11.4       5.6 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    49                     :
:       15        17         .         0         0         4         7         .        10         5         6 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CALIFORNIA CARBON ALLOWANCE VINTAGE 2015 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   1,000 california carbon allowanc           :
CFTC Code #006393                                                    Open Interest is     6,150                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:    4,196       757       183     4,866        50         0         0         0     1,711       476         0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:     -135       -28         0         0         0         0         0         0       125        18      -148 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     68.2      12.3       3.0      79.1       0.8       0.0       0.0       0.0      27.8       7.7       0.0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    20                     :
:        6         4         .         .         .         0         0         0         5         .         0 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CALIF CARBON ALL VINTAGE 2016 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   1,000 california carbon allowances                    :
CFTC Code #00639H                                                    Open Interest is    34,756                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   16,628    16,472     2,805     7,515     1,250         0         0         0     9,642     5,189     4,330 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:   -1,291    -2,339       375         0      -283         0         0         0      -983       460      -437 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     47.8      47.4       8.1      21.6       3.6       0.0       0.0       0.0      27.7      14.9      12.5 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    33                     :
:       10         9         .         .         .         0         0         0         9         9         9 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NJ SRECS VINTAGE 2017 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   (10 SRECs)                                                    :
CFTC Code #00639W                                                    Open Interest is    34,260                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   15,150    22,000         0         0         0         0         0         0    18,510    11,660       600 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:      -50        50         0         0         0         0         0         0        90       -10      -240 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     44.2      64.2       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0      54.0      34.0       1.8 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    25                     :
:        8         5         0         0         0         0         0         0         6         7         . :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NJ SRECS VINTAGE 2018 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   (10 SRECs)                                                    :
CFTC Code #00639X                                                    Open Interest is    28,215                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   21,565    10,750         0         0         0         0         0         0     6,435    17,230       195 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:      100       450         0         0         0         0         0         0       200      -150         0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     76.4      38.1       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0      22.8      61.1       0.7 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    26                     :
:       10         4         0         0         0         0         0         0         6         9         . :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CALIF CARBON ALL VINTAGE 2017 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   1,000 california carbon allowances                    :
CFTC Code #00639Y                                                    Open Interest is    29,434                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   22,830    12,776       714    12,900        65         0         0         0     2,624       493     3,200 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:      436       110         3         0         0         0         0         0      -851      -522       403 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     77.6      43.4       2.4      43.8       0.2       0.0       0.0       0.0       8.9       1.7      10.9 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    25                     :
:        9         6         .         .         .         0         0         0         8         .         5 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RGGI VINTAGE 2016 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   1,000 RGGI CO2 Allowances                                         :
CFTC Code #0063A1                                                    Open Interest is    69,004                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   43,251    30,297         0    17,144    13,436         0         0         0     7,465     3,250     4,831 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:     -174      -332       -89       933      -883         0         0         0       -22      -888       -28 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     62.7      43.9       0.0      24.8      19.5       0.0       0.0       0.0      10.8       4.7       7.0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    32                     :
:       16        12         0         .         .         0         0         0         6         6         7 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NJ SRECS VINTAGE 2019 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   (10 SRECs)                                                    :
CFTC Code #0063A3                                                    Open Interest is    18,110                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   14,300     8,850         0         0         0         0         0         0     3,400     8,860       400 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:      200       100         0         0         0         0         0         0       100       200         0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     79.0      48.9       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0      18.8      48.9       2.2 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    24                     :
:        7         5         0         0         0         0         0         0         6         7         . :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PJM TRI-RECs CLASS 1 Vin 2017 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   100 MWh of renewable energy certificates              :
CFTC Code #0063AA                                                    Open Interest is    18,374                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:    9,384     9,654         0         0         0     1,495         0         0     7,275     8,520       200 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:     -249       256         0         0         0       255         0         0       250         0       -70 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     51.1      52.5       0.0       0.0       0.0       8.1       0.0       0.0      39.6      46.4       1.1 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    24                     :
:        8         8         0         0         0         .         0         0         6         4         . :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PJM TRI-RECs CLASS 1 Vin 2018 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   100 MWh of renewable energy certificates              :
CFTC Code #0063AB                                                    Open Interest is    19,285                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:    9,276    10,685         0         0         0     3,144         0         0     5,465     7,200     1,400 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:      150       291         0         0         0        41         0         0       600       500         0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     48.1      55.4       0.0       0.0       0.0      16.3       0.0       0.0      28.3      37.3       7.3 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    24                     :
:        9         4         0         0         0         .         0         0         8         .         . :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 1, 2016  
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PJM TRI-RECs CLASS 1 Vin 2019 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   100 MWh of renewable energy certificates              :
CFTC Code #0063AD                                                    Open Interest is    11,695                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:    4,225     5,500         0         0         0     1,300         0         0     6,070     6,095       100 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     October 25, 2016                                                                           :
:      550       750         0         0         0         0         0         0       600       400         0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     36.1      47.0       0.0       0.0       0.0      11.1       0.0       0.0      51.9      52.1       0.9 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    20                     :
:        7         4         0         0         0         .         0         0         4         4         . :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Updated November 4, 2016