Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PALLADIUM - NEW YORK MERCANTILE EXCHANGE   (CONTRACTS OF 100 TROY OUNCES)                                      :
CFTC Code #075651                                                    Open Interest is    27,967                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:    2,049    13,753     2,208     3,655     2,155    13,576     1,164     1,900     3,709     3,817       115 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:     -373     1,731      -373       670        39     2,068    -1,049     1,439     1,148     1,146      -146 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:      7.3      49.2       7.9      13.1       7.7      48.5       4.2       6.8      13.3      13.6       0.4 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:   163                     :
:       10        24        11        14        14        47        11        10        27        24         4 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PLATINUM - NEW YORK MERCANTILE EXCHANGE   (CONTRACTS OF 50 TROY OUNCES)                                        :
CFTC Code #076651                                                    Open Interest is    67,542                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:    4,749    28,934     5,362     8,457     1,962    26,904    18,373     1,984    19,476     3,510       416 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:      -62     1,086       550       455       -24     1,314     2,622      -226       622    -1,353      -139 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:      7.0      42.8       7.9      12.5       2.9      39.8      27.2       2.9      28.8       5.2       0.6 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:   232                     :
:       19        21        12        14         8        48        33        18        74        16         6 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SILVER - COMMODITY EXCHANGE INC.   (CONTRACTS OF 5,000 TROY OUNCES)                                            :
CFTC Code #084691                                                    Open Interest is   185,304                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   12,578    63,540    23,070    51,605    15,571    58,473    15,627     8,700    23,992     6,346    12,214 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:     -917        70      -445    -3,822    -4,771    -6,210      -449      -824       775       -80    -3,268 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:      6.8      34.3      12.4      27.8       8.4      31.6       8.4       4.7      12.9       3.4       6.6 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:   203                     :
:       21        23        12        12        17        44        24        26        50        27        39 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
GOLD - COMMODITY EXCHANGE INC.   (CONTRACTS OF 100 TROY OUNCES)                                                :
CFTC Code #088691                                                    Open Interest is   634,083                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   40,093   134,351    23,617   115,148   110,955   170,982    49,747    64,447    64,827    27,347   105,149 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:  -12,793   -18,998    -1,155    -8,479   -24,062    -4,355     6,475    -6,213    -1,548     3,645   -26,882 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:      6.3      21.2       3.7      18.2      17.5      27.0       7.8      10.2      10.2       4.3      16.6 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:   344                     :
:       29        30        15        16        24        67        47        54       102        55        78 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
COPPER-GRADE #1 - COMMODITY EXCHANGE INC.   (CONTRACTS OF 25,000 POUNDS)                                       :
CFTC Code #085692                                                    Open Interest is   237,190                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   25,296   104,441    41,775    10,582     1,023   100,427    24,081    13,503    17,517    47,594    19,184 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:   -1,784     3,333      -521      -676      -910     3,453    -2,346     1,095    -2,995     1,306    -1,697 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     10.7      44.0      17.6       4.5       0.4      42.3      10.2       5.7       7.4      20.1       8.1 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:   328                     :
:       31        52        17         6         8        93        30        35        43        70        54 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ALUMINUM MW US TR PLATTS SWAP - COMMODITY EXCHANGE INC.   (25 METRIC TONS)                                     :
CFTC Code #191693                                                    Open Interest is    33,579                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   11,759    31,939     6,236       525        45     2,690         0         0    12,557       452         0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:    1,969     2,311        72         0         2       540         0         0        60       240       -24 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     35.0      95.1      18.6       1.6       0.1       8.0       0.0       0.0      37.4       1.3       0.0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    27                     :
:        8        17         .         .         .         .         0         0         .         .         0 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
HOT ROLLED COIL STEEL - NEW YORK MERCANTILE EXCHANGE   (CONTRACTS OF 20 SHORT TONS)                            :
CFTC Code #192651                                                    Open Interest is    17,214                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:    2,501       572     7,345         0         0       454     2,322        39     5,804    13,388       781 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:      -24        97       268         0         0      -234      -204       -91       -38       305       -97 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     14.5       3.3      42.7       0.0       0.0       2.6      13.5       0.2      33.7      77.8       4.5 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    23                     :
:        7         4         .         0         0         .         .         .         6         .         4 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IRON ORE 62% FE, CFR CHINA TSI - NEW YORK MERCANTILE EXCHANGE   (CONTRACTS OF 500 DRY METRIC TONS)             :
CFTC Code #195651                                                    Open Interest is    18,977                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:    5,380     5,778         0         0         0     1,504     5,052       410     6,796     2,995     4,399 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:       28       370         0         0         0        90        75        40        22      -178       353 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     28.4      30.4       0.0       0.0       0.0       7.9      26.6       2.2      35.8      15.8      23.2 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    63                     :
:       15        14         0         0         0         6         7         .        21        12        23 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IRON ORE 62% FE CFR N CHNA APO - NEW YORK MERCANTILE EXCHANGE   (CONTRACTS OF 500 DRY METRIC TONS)             :
CFTC Code #195653                                                    Open Interest is    11,858                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:    1,104     3,167         0         0         0     2,541       597     1,700     1,305     1,279     5,057 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:      -13       136         0         0         0       216         4         0       -83        85       223 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:      9.3      26.7       0.0       0.0       0.0      21.4       5.0      14.3      11.0      10.8      42.6 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    24                     :
:        8         7         0         0         0         .         4         4         5         5         6 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RANDOM LENGTH LUMBER - CHICAGO MERCANTILE EXCHANGE   (CONTRACTS OF 110,000 BOARD FEET)                         :
CFTC Code #058643                                                    Open Interest is     4,048                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:      908     1,561        90         0         0       677       822        22       906       525       253 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:     -190       -60        -1         0         0        77      -177         5       -90       -35        66 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     22.4      38.6       2.2       0.0       0.0      16.7      20.3       0.5      22.4      13.0       6.2 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    53                     :
:       12        17         .         0         0         8         7         .        10         4         8 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CALIF CARBON ALL VINTAGE 2016 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   1,000 california carbon allowances                    :
CFTC Code #00639H                                                    Open Interest is    35,208                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   17,344    17,286     2,538     7,515     1,552         0         0         0    10,893     6,033     2,811 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:      330        91      -220         0       300         0         0         0       689       708      -774 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     49.3      49.1       7.2      21.3       4.4       0.0       0.0       0.0      30.9      17.1       8.0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    35                     :
:       10         9         .         .         .         0         0         0        11         9         9 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NJ SRECS VINTAGE 2017 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   (10 SRECs)                                                    :
CFTC Code #00639W                                                    Open Interest is    34,110                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   14,600    21,600         0         0         0         0         0         0    18,910    11,910       600 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:     -600      -350         0         0         0         0         0         0       250         0         0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     42.8      63.3       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0      55.4      34.9       1.8 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    25                     :
:        8         5         0         0         0         0         0         0         7         6         . :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NJ SRECS VINTAGE 2018 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   (10 SRECs)                                                    :
CFTC Code #00639X                                                    Open Interest is    30,230                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   23,315    11,194         0         0         0         0         0         0     6,724    18,865       171 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:      500         0         0         0         0         0         0         0      -400       100         0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     77.1      37.0       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0      22.2      62.4       0.6 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    27                     :
:        9         5         0         0         0         0         0         0         7         9         . :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CALIF CARBON ALL VINTAGE 2017 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   1,000 california carbon allowances                    :
CFTC Code #00639Y                                                    Open Interest is    28,949                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   22,025    12,596       594    12,900       120         0         0         0     3,506       630     2,704 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:     -827       100      -108         0        55         0         0         0     1,179       145      -908 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     76.1      43.5       2.1      44.6       0.4       0.0       0.0       0.0      12.1       2.2       9.3 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    25                     :
:        9         7         .         .         .         0         0         0         7         4         5 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RGGI VINTAGE 2016 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   1,000 RGGI CO2 Allowances                                         :
CFTC Code #0063A1                                                    Open Interest is    78,158                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   49,058    35,204         0    18,003    17,726         0         0         0     7,508     3,328     3,865 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:      258        33         0        19     2,014         0         0         0      -179        27     1,501 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     62.8      45.0       0.0      23.0      22.7       0.0       0.0       0.0       9.6       4.3       4.9 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    33                     :
:       16        12         0         .         .         0         0         0         6         7         8 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NJ SRECS VINTAGE 2019 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   (10 SRECs)                                                    :
CFTC Code #0063A3                                                    Open Interest is    18,435                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   14,400     8,850         0         0         0         0         0         0     3,425     9,035       550 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:      400       300         0         0         0         0         0         0      -200      -100       150 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     78.1      48.0       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0      18.6      49.0       3.0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    25                     :
:        7         5         0         0         0         0         0         0         7         7         . :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NJ SRECS VINTAGE 2020 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   (10 SRECs)                                                    :
CFTC Code #0063A4                                                    Open Interest is     7,047                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:    2,800     3,455         0         0         0         0         0         0     4,247     3,587         0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:      100       445         0         0         0         0         0         0       325       -25         0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     39.7      49.0       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0       0.0      60.3      50.9       0.0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    20                     :
:        5         .         0         0         0         0         0         0         7         5         0 :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PJM TRI-RECs CLASS 1 Vin 2017 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   100 MWh of renewable energy certificates              :
CFTC Code #0063AA                                                    Open Interest is    16,838                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:    8,578     8,673         0         0         0     1,240         0         0     6,800     7,965       200 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:     -218      -276         0         0         0       -64         0         0        50        45         0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     50.9      51.5       0.0       0.0       0.0       7.4       0.0       0.0      40.4      47.3       1.2 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    22                     :
:        8         8         0         0         0         .         0         0         5         .         . :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PJM TRI-RECs CLASS 1 Vin 2018 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   100 MWh of renewable energy certificates              :
CFTC Code #0063AB                                                    Open Interest is    20,234                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:   10,306    11,884         0         0         0     3,118         0         0     5,410     6,950     1,400 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:     -300       -14         0         0         0       -14         0         0       200      -100         0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     50.9      58.7       0.0       0.0       0.0      15.4       0.0       0.0      26.7      34.3       6.9 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    24                     :
:        9         4         0         0         0         .         0         0         6         5         . :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disaggregated Commitments of Traders- Options and Futures Combined Positions as of November 22, 2016 
:                                             Reportable Positions                                             :
:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :
: Producer/Merchant :                             :                             :                              :
:  Processor/User   :        Swap Dealers         :        Managed Money        :      Other Reportables       :
:   Long  :  Short  :   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading:   Long  :  Short  :Spreading :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PJM TRI-RECs CLASS 1 Vin 2019 - ICE FUTURES ENERGY DIV   100 MWh of renewable energy certificates              :
CFTC Code #0063AD                                                    Open Interest is    13,445                :
: Positions                                                                                                    :
:    5,075     6,595         0         0         0     1,300         0         0     6,970     6,750       100 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Changes from:     November 15, 2016                                                                          :
:      200       445         0         0         0         0         0         0       750       505         0 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Percent of Open Interest Represented by Each Category of Trader                                              :
:     37.7      49.1       0.0       0.0       0.0       9.7       0.0       0.0      51.8      50.2       0.7 :
:                                                                                                              :
: Number of Traders in Each Category                                  Total Traders:    20                     :
:        8         .         0         0         0         .         0         0         4         4         . :
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Updated November 25, 2016